C.S. Lewis

C.S. Lewis

Saturday, August 16, 2014

Bartram: Naturalism Points to Christian Salvation



"The higher powers and affections of the soul are so blended and connected with the inferior passions, that the most painful feelings are excited in the mind with the latter are crossed; thus in the moral system, which we have planned for our conduct, as a ladder whereby to mount to the summit of terrestrial glory and happiness, and from whence we perhaps meditated our flight to heaven itself, at the very moment when we vainly imagine ourselves to have attained its point, some unforeseen accident intervenes, and surprises us."  William Bartram
         Bartram, a naturalist at the end of the 18th century and beginning of the 19th, makes some interesting points in this statement: He notes the irreversible connection between a man’s soul and his sinful, broken human nature. The result of the two being contained within the same vessel is a constant, inescapable crossing between the two.  He stipulates that, if the two are placed at odds, the result is a painful emotional response.  This response could be remorse, anger, guilt, etc.  For example, if a person makes a mistake or wrongs another, his conscience or soul is at odds with his sin nature. 
         According to the passage, the general morality system to which mankind aligns its actions, is an institution by which we try to reach a type of enlightenment or higher state of being.  Morals are, to a person in pain from his sins, a way to escape his sins through being “good.”  This code is often used with the goal of attaining absolution and a “flight to heaven” after perfect compliance with generic morality standards. 
         The conclusion of this passage takes a darker tone.  After taking us to an emotional high with references to a correlation between heaven and good deeds, Bertram takes us back down to reality.  Man’s human nature is, after all, ever dragging us down as said in the previous statements about “inferior passions.”  Due to our sin nature, a perfect life is not attainable.  A person might get a temporary euphoria from doing a good deed and believe him/herself to have attained perfection, but it is short-lived.  Our human inclination is to sin, and therefore it is impossible to achieve nirvana, good karma, absolution, or any other type of morality-based salvation.       
While Bartram held the naturalist worldview that only the laws of nature govern the world and there is no supernatural influence, this statement spans worldviews for its analysis of the connection between a soul and sin actions.  I leave it to the reader to perceive the origin of true salvation but my conclusion is that salvation is through the Judeo-Christian God who, when asked, forgives your sins and accepts you into Heaven through faith in Jesus Christ).  As far as Bartram’s beliefs, based on his statements on the impossibility of attaining salvation through works consider this:


Can you really be saved from yourself by yourself?